Establish a dedicated agent policy

This commit is contained in:
2026-09-25 20:25:36 +00:00
parent 53d9284f0b
commit cc51b8470a
6 changed files with 98 additions and 35 deletions

View File

@@ -1,7 +1,5 @@
Please review `docs/development.md` for initial orientation in this repository
and follow its task-specific reading guide.
For every planning and implementation task, follow the
[`Implementation Discipline`](docs/policy/architecture.md#implementation-discipline):
keep machinery proportionate, do not invent restrictions, and do not elevate
incidental implementation details into repository policy.
Review and follow `docs/policy/agents.md` before recommending, planning, or
implementing any changes to this repository.

View File

@@ -9,6 +9,9 @@ the [README](../README.md) for product context, [Architecture](policy/architectu
for system boundaries, and [Internal Overview](internal/overview.md) for the
implemented component map.
Read [Agent Policy](policy/agents.md) before recommending, planning, or
implementing changes. It owns implementation discipline and local commit rules.
## What To Read
| When working on | Read | Why |

90
docs/policy/agents.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,90 @@
# Agent Policy
**Base Policy Version:** 1.1
**Last Updated**: 2026-09-25
**Upstream Source:** `policy` commit `45591a79004c6811950f14dca554f6ff69b7f58e`.
Notarius adaptations preserve operator choice, existing explicit contracts, and
the deployment-permissions example below.
## Purpose
Agents working in this repository must read and adhere to the following house rules.
## Implementation Discipline
Simplify the mechanism, not the user's choices.
**KEY PRINCIPLES:** Write the simplest idiomatic code that satisfies the user's
request. Do not implicitly strengthen requirements, restrictions, or guarantees
beyond what the user actually requested.
**Keep implementation machinery proportionate.** Use straightforward,
idiomatic code and introduce only the machinery needed to support the requested
behavior and flexibility. Optimize for conceptual simplicity and
maintainability, not for the fewest lines, fewest options, or narrowest product
surface.
**Do not invent restrictions.** Do not reject, prohibit, constrain, cap,
harden, or otherwise narrow behavior unless required by the user, an explicit
repository contract, or an unavoidable correctness constraint. Preserve
operator and caller choice where policy has not been established. If an
additional restriction appears advisable, present it as a decision rather than
silently implementing it.
**Do not invent guarantees.** Do not strengthen public contracts, guarantees,
or invariants beyond those expressly requested by the user.
**Use the standard library.** For example: in almost every case, the best
approach to copying files is to use the standard library. Writing custom code to
implement power-loss protection at the application level, or to guard against
bad actors with privileged and concurrent access to the host's filesystem,
is wasteful, unnecessary, and not idiomatic. Stick to the simple, standard, and
idiomatic approach unless another path is expressly requested by the user.
**An implementation detail is not repository policy.** Tests and documentation
must not elevate incidental behavior into a durable guarantee or restriction
unless that behavior was expressly selected as part of the contract. Existing
explicit contracts remain authoritative; changing or weakening one requires a
deliberate decision rather than being inferred from these principles.
[ADR-0017](../adr/0017-defer-cache-access-policy-to-deployment.md) illustrates
why Unix deployments own cache access policy through permissions, umask, setgid,
and default ACLs. Notarius retains its separately adopted correctness boundaries.
## Git Commit Policy
By default, create a commit after completing each coherent unit of work, using a
concise, plain-English message describing what changed. This policy is standing
authorization to create those local commits; a separate user request is not
required. An explicit user instruction to leave work uncommitted takes precedence.
A unit of work is a focused, reviewable outcome, including its relevant tests and
documentation. Do not commit after every intermediate edit or create empty commits.
Complete the appropriate validation before committing. If work is incomplete or
validation is blocked, report that state rather than presenting it as completed.
Before committing:
1. Run `git status --short` and review the relevant diff, including any staged
changes. Identify changes that predate the current unit of work.
2. Exclude secrets, local environment files, generated junk, and unrelated changes.
3. Stage only the files or hunks belonging to the completed unit. Use `git add .`
only when every included change belongs to that unit. Do not disturb unrelated
staged or unstaged work.
4. Review `git diff --staged` and run appropriate checks for the change. Do not
repeat checks already passed for unchanged content merely to create a commit.
5. Review `git log --oneline -n 10` and use
`git commit -m "<concise plain-English commit message>"`.
6. Report the commit identifier and any remaining uncommitted work.
If the unit cannot be safely separated from pre-existing work, leave it uncommitted
and explain the overlap rather than silently including that work. If a commit
fails, preserve the changes and report the failure; do not bypass hooks.
Default commit authorization does not authorize pushing, publishing, amending,
resetting, reverting, or rewriting history. Those actions require a separate user
instruction. Do not use `git commit -a` or `git commit --no-verify` to bypass the
staging and validation discipline above.

View File

@@ -38,35 +38,7 @@ Notarius is contract-first without being abstraction-heavy. Interfaces and
extension points should protect demonstrated boundaries. New abstraction is not
itself an architectural goal.
## Implementation Discipline
Simplify the mechanism, not the user's choices.
**Keep implementation machinery proportionate.** Use straightforward,
idiomatic code and introduce only the machinery needed to support the requested
behavior and flexibility. Optimize for conceptual simplicity and
maintainability, not for the fewest lines, fewest options, or narrowest product
surface.
**Do not invent restrictions.** Do not reject, prohibit, constrain, cap,
harden, or otherwise narrow behavior unless required by the user, an explicit
repository contract, or an unavoidable correctness constraint. Preserve
operator and caller choice where policy has not been established. If an
additional restriction appears advisable, present it as a decision rather than
silently implementing it.
**An implementation detail is not repository policy.** Tests and documentation
must not elevate incidental behavior into a durable guarantee or restriction
unless that behavior was expressly selected as part of the contract. Existing
explicit contracts remain authoritative; changing or weakening one requires a
deliberate decision rather than being inferred from this principle.
[ADR-0017](../adr/0017-defer-cache-access-policy-to-deployment.md) illustrates
these principles. Notarius previously elevated private cache creation modes
into application policy even though Unix deployments already express access
policy through directory permissions, process umask, setgid inheritance, and
default ACLs. The revised design retains application-owned correctness
boundaries while leaving deployment security policy to the operator.
Implementation discipline is owned by [Agent Policy](agents.md).
## Layers And Dependency Direction

View File

@@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ policy, default, or limit as authoritative merely because the current code
implements it. Documentation may accurately describe current behavior without
making it a permanent requirement; distinguish descriptive behavior from
normative policy. The
[implementation-discipline rules](architecture.md#implementation-discipline)
[implementation-discipline rules](agents.md#implementation-discipline)
own the criteria for adopting product restrictions and for elevating behavior
into repository policy.

View File

@@ -91,7 +91,7 @@ Tests must not create a stronger product contract than the requirement they
protect. In particular, do not turn an incidental limit, restriction,
permission choice, validation rule, or implementation default into policy by
asserting it without an expressly selected contract. Follow the
[implementation-discipline rules](architecture.md#implementation-discipline)
[implementation-discipline rules](agents.md#implementation-discipline)
when deciding what behavior deserves durable protection.
Before adding or retaining a test, ask: